Your Community
Deserves Better
Protection
Personalized insurance solutions rooted in local trust. Jennifer Fagen and the Neighbor Insurance team protect what matters most — your home, your family, your future.
Comprehensive Coverage
for Every Stage of Life
From your first home to your growing business, we provide tailored insurance solutions that adapt to your changing needs.
Homeowners Insurance
Protect your home — your biggest investment — against unforeseen events with comprehensive coverage tailored to your property and lifestyle.
Learn moreAuto Insurance
Drive with confidence. We offer full-coverage and liability options that fit your driving habits and budget, with claims support that actually shows up.
Learn moreLife Insurance
Secure your family's financial future with term, whole, and universal life policies designed around your goals and generational needs.
Learn moreRenters Insurance
Your belongings deserve protection too. Affordable renters coverage for your possessions, liability, and temporary living expenses if disaster strikes.
Learn moreBusiness Insurance
Whether you run a shop, a service, or a startup — we craft commercial policies that shield your assets, employees, and reputation.
Learn moreUmbrella Policies
Extra liability coverage that steps in when your standard policies fall short — giving you peace of mind beyond the baseline limits.
Learn more
A Neighbor Who
Actually Cares
Neighbor Insurance was founded on a simple belief: insurance should feel less like a transaction and more like a conversation with someone who knows your name — and your risks.
Based right here in Keota, Jennifer Fagen brings a personal, community-first approach to every policy. No pushy sales tactics. No confusing jargon. Just honest guidance that helps you understand exactly what you're covered for — and what you might be missing.
Why Clients Stay
Personal Relationships
You'll know your agent by name. We remember your story, your concerns, and the details that matter.
Claims That Move
When something goes wrong, we don't disappear. Our team advocates for you through every step of the claims process.
Tailored Coverage
No cookie-cutter policies. We design coverage around your actual life — not a generic template.
Local & Accessible
Right here in Keota. No call centers, no wait times. Just a phone call or a visit to our office.
Trusted by Neighbors
"Jennifer took the time to explain every option without pressure. I finally understand what my policy covers — and it gives me real peace of mind."
"When we had to file a claim after a severe storm, Neighbor Insurance was there from day one. They made a stressful situation manageable."
"Switching to Neighbor Insurance was the best decision. They bundled our home and auto policies and saved us money while improving our coverage."
Don't Wait for the
Unexpected
A free consultation takes less than 15 minutes and could save you thousands. Let's review your coverage and find gaps before they become problems.
Let's Start a
Conversation
Whether you need a policy review, a new quote, or just have questions — we're here. Reach out by phone, email, or stop by our office.
Keota, IA 52248-8647
